Montauk Seafood Company

Home
United States
Montauk, NY
Montauk Seafood Company

A family owned and operated fish market in downtown Montauk offering only the freshest, locally sour

05/23/2025

Looking for that perfect steak for your Memorial Day Weekend BBQ? We have got you covered at Montauk Seafood Company. We carry only the best US Prime beef hand cut to any size you would like. We also have Wagyu beef burgers and all the fixings. Custom orders and cuts are always available with advanced order. Stop down and get all you need for the weekend.

11/19/2024

Buying direct from local baymen guarantee we have the best quality fish and shellfish available for our customers. These amazing bay scallops were caught by local shellfish diver this am and shucked for you this afternoon.

Everyone enjoys free stuff, with that being said the person to correctly guess the weight of scallop meats from today’s haul will receive a free pound of local bay scallops. Weight to nearest tenth of a pound. Winner will be announced on Friday.

06/04/2024

Montauk Seafood Company is looking for part time retail help this summer. Call 631 668-5957 or send me a message for more info.

11/18/2023

Hand picked and hand cut, every damn day. Nothing but the best for our customers.

10/06/2023

Usually a local spring time delicacy, we are super excited to be getting a small run of blowfish straight from the local baymen. We don’t have many but they are available at both and on the special menu. Hurry down as they won’t last long.

08/05/2023

Quality seafood starts with the fishermen. We buy from the best to bring you the best. Beautiful Montauk Striped bass shining like diamonds! Available at both and in East Hampton.

07/08/2023

The true definition of meat without feet. Local bone-in swordfish “Ribeyes” straight from get them quick because they won’t last long.

07/07/2023

Rachycentron canadum or commonly known as Cobia, is a predominantly southern fish. But every summer a handful make their way up the coast to our local waters. Super limited amount available only .

06/11/2023

Creatures from the deep! Capt. Rudi from F/V Ragnar with the freshest of the fresh. Picked up off the boat this morning and in the case within the hour. Nothing but the best for our customers. Available in Montauk and in East Hampton. Both stores open till 6pm.

06/06/2023

Another midnight market run in the books. With all our local fishermen landing our favorites in Montauk, we decided to step outside the box and get some exotics for this week. On tap is wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, Yellowtail snappers, and gorgeous mutton snapper from Florida. Open everyday 11-6.

05/17/2023

Another midnight market run in the books. Being able to hand select each fish that goes in our case, let’s you get the best quality fish for your dinner plate. On tap for this week is Florida Red Grouper from Cortez Florida, Striped Bass from Montauk’s famous Capt. Rob Aaronson of the F/V Oh Brother and gorgeous day boat scallops from the F/V Glutton out of Provincetown, MA. Starting next week we will be open seven days a week.

05/10/2023

Fresh North Carolina soft shells in the case this week. We also have fresh Florida Black Grouper, local fluke, and day boat Sea Scallops to name a few.

Address

12 S Etna Avenue
Montauk, NY
11954

Telephone

+16316685957

Website

http://Montaukseafoodcompany.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Montauk Seafood Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Montauk Seafood Company:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Grocery Store in Montauk?