The Better Bagel

11/16/2025

🍁 NEW! Harvest Farro Salad 🍁
Fall flavors are officially here at The Better Bagel!

Our Harvest Farro Salad is packed with:
✨ Farro grain
✨ Roasted butternut squash
✨ Roasted shaved Brussels sprouts
✨ Caramelized shallots
✨ Pumpkin seeds & craisins
✨ Finished with an apple cider vinaigrette

Wholesome, seasonal, and absolutely delicious.
Grab yours today!

11/14/2025

This week’s Flavor of the Week is Spinach & Artichoke and OMG… you need to try it. 😍
Spread it. Dip it. Love it.
Only at The Better Bagel!

04/23/2023

Stop at the better bagel in Amityville and get your New York Islanders bagel before game 4 this afternoon!

Yes Yes Yes!

01/15/2022

The Better Bagel National Bagel Day $20 gift card giveaway!

Enter to win by following the steps below.

1. Follow The Better Bagel on Instagram
2. Tag 3 friends in comments
2. Upload a photo of our bagels or egg sandwiches and tag us so we can share on our story!

Entry deadline is Saturday January 22nd.

Three lucky winners will be chosen at random! Winners will be announced on Monday January 24th!

11/18/2021

Order Online! https://order.chownow.com/order/10766/locations/14779

10/20/2021

Soups!
Lemon Chicken Orzo
Cream of Broccoli
Lobster Bisque
Chicken Kale Quinoa

06/29/2021

The Better Bagel and Country Roads Catering are hiring for all positions.

Counter Help
Kitchen Prep
Catering Associate
Waitstaff
Delivery
Grill Person

Part Time and Full Time shifts available !

Best Bagels, Salad Bar, Sandwiches, Heros, Catering, Soups, Egg Sandwiches, Online Ordering, Party Heros, The Better Bagel

03/02/2021

Open Tomorrow!
6am to 4pm

$6.99 Wednesday Dozen Special

02/24/2021

Thank you Sarah and Tara!! 💕

02/23/2021

We hope this brings some smiles to our customers during these crazy times and will satisfy your bagel craving until we reopen next week!!

Tomorrow morning, between 7am and 12pm The Better Bagel will be giving out FREE 1 dozen bags of freshly baked bagels and half lbs of cream cheese.

The bags will be be assorted and available in the vestibule for contactless pick up along with containers of cream cheese.

We will not be selling any other product and we won’t be able to take any special requests for bagels.

Enjoy and stay safe!!

02/23/2021

To our loyal customers!

The Better Bagel, out of an abundance of caution, will be closed temporarily starting tomorrow.

Our number one priority is the safety of our staff and customers. We have decided to close temporarily to deep clean and sanitize the store. We will follow all CDC and health department guidelines to make sure we reopen safely. We can’t thank you enough for your support during these crazy and difficult times. If you have any questions you can e-mail us at [email protected]

Stay safe!
The Better Bagel Staff