The Cheese Shop

The Cheese Shop The Cape May creamery! Specialty cheeses, charcuterie boards, sandwiches, gourmet food products, & more in America's original seaside resort. 🧀🇺🇸

It is shaping up to be an exciting Labor Day Weekend in Cape May! Stop by our shop all weekend long for specialty cheese...
09/04/2026

It is shaping up to be an exciting Labor Day Weekend in Cape May! Stop by our shop all weekend long for specialty cheeses, charcuterie boards, sandwiches, gourmet food products, & more in America's original seaside resort. 🧀☀

September 2nd is World Coconut Day! 🥥 The house-made Lemon & Coconut Italian Biscotti by our sister shop Cape May Olive ...
09/02/2026

September 2nd is World Coconut Day! 🥥 The house-made Lemon & Coconut Italian Biscotti by our sister shop Cape May Olive Oil Co. that we carry is perfect with coffee, fine teas, Vin Santo, red wines, or as a late night treat. Find it in the shop or online at capeislandfoods.com/product/lemon-coconut-italian-biscotti/MGHSVLLOGBAKMFAD4GEKKD6L.

August 31st is National Eat Outside Day! Grab your favorites from The Cheese Shop and enjoy them in the Cape May sunshin...
08/28/2026

August 31st is National Eat Outside Day! Grab your favorites from The Cheese Shop and enjoy them in the Cape May sunshine! Find a bench along the Washington Street Mall, head to the beach or park, or pick your favorite outdoor spot to savor our gourmet cheeses, artisanal sandwiches, and more. ☀

Say cheese, newlyweds! 🧀💍The Knot has named Cape May one of the “Best Honeymoon Destinations in the USA,” and we can’t t...
08/24/2026

Say cheese, newlyweds! 🧀💍

The Knot has named Cape May one of the “Best Honeymoon Destinations in the USA,” and we can’t think of a better place to celebrate your newlywed getaway!

Between romantic dinners, beautiful beaches, charming streets, and plenty of shopping, there’s so much to enjoy together. While you’re exploring town, stop by The Cheese Shop and pick up some cheesy favorites, spreads, and gourmet goodies to enjoy during your stay — or bring home as a delicious reminder of your Cape May honeymoon. ❤️

Cape May has Christmas charm down to an art — and now our hometown could be the backdrop for a new Hallmark movie! 🎬🎄Cap...
08/21/2026

Cape May has Christmas charm down to an art — and now our hometown could be the backdrop for a new Hallmark movie! 🎬🎄

Cape May is a finalist in Hallmark’s Merriest Christmas Town contest, and the grand prize-winning town will have the opportunity to serve as a filming location for a future Hallmark original movie.

Between holiday shopping, festive treats, and picking up something delicious for your holiday gatherings, Christmas is one of our favorite times of year here at The Cheese Shop. 🧀🎁 We’d love to see all the holiday magic that makes Cape May so special featured in a new Hallmark production!

🗳️ Cast your vote daily through September 4th via the link listed on capemayfirstandonly.com/post/vote-for-cape-may-in-hallmark-channel-s-merriest-christmas-towns-contest.

We know you love stopping by The Cheese Shop, and now we're asking for your vote in this year's Cape May.com Best of Cap...
08/17/2026

We know you love stopping by The Cheese Shop, and now we're asking for your vote in this year's Cape May.com Best of Cape May awards! 🧀

🥪 Vote The Cheese Shop for Best Sandwich, Wrap, or Hoagie!

From freshly made sandwiches to plenty of cheesy goodness, we're grateful to be part of your Cape May traditions.

Voting is open through August 24th at capemay.com/best. Please note that you must vote in at least 10 categories for your votes to be counted.

Thanks for showing The Cheese Shop some love! 🧀❤️

August is National Sandwich Month! Fresh bread, top-tier cheese, and flavor-packed fillings. Our grab-and-go sandwiches ...
08/14/2026

August is National Sandwich Month! Fresh bread, top-tier cheese, and flavor-packed fillings. Our grab-and-go sandwiches are such a taste sensation, you’ll want to eat them right away here on the Mall. Come try one today!

🐾 August 10th is National Spoil Your Dog Day! Our Parmesan & Cheddar Dog Treats are a paw-fect treat to spoil your pup w...
08/10/2026

🐾 August 10th is National Spoil Your Dog Day! Our Parmesan & Cheddar Dog Treats are a paw-fect treat to spoil your pup with! These treats are irresistibly delicious and pair well with just about anything. Plus, a portion of all sales go towards pet-based programs. 🐶🧀 Shop in-store or online at capeislandfoods.com/product/parmesan-cheddar-dog-treats/QBDMSBBGZD7YJBLVJ6S2XBWZ.

08/08/2026

From cheeses and savory spreads to all the little extras that make a good spread even better, stop in and browse while you’re enjoying a day in Cape May.

August is National Goat Cheese Month! If you're a goat cheese fan, this one's for you. Creamy, tangy, and perfectly spre...
08/06/2026

August is National Goat Cheese Month! If you're a goat cheese fan, this one's for you. Creamy, tangy, and perfectly spreadable, our Goat Cheese Cherry Spread and Goat Cheese Apricot Spread pair rich goat cheese with just the right touch of fruit.

Spread them on crackers, layer them onto a sandwich, or add them to your next charcuterie board for an easy crowd-pleaser.

Address

304 Washington Street
Cape May, NJ
NJ

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 9pm
Tuesday 10am - 9pm
Wednesday 10am - 9pm
Thursday 10am - 9pm
Friday 10am - 9pm
Saturday 10am - 9pm
Sunday 10am - 9pm

Telephone

+16093054080

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cheese Shop posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Cheese Shop:

Shortcuts

Share

Category