Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations

Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations In our store you will find a variety of items but our most popular items are our delicious fried pie and award winning cheeses!
(3)

We have many great flavors to choose from! Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry
Lemon
Cheesecake
Coconut Cream

Seasonal Flavors:
Bavarian
Chocolate
Rhubarb
Strawberry
Strawberry/Rhubarb
Pecan (September - December)
Pumpkin (October - November)

Father’s Day is coming up.Dad may need to stop in this week and do a little “research.”You know… test out the fried pie ...
06/17/2026

Father’s Day is coming up.

Dad may need to stop in this week and do a little “research.”

You know… test out the fried pie flavors, confirm which ones are his favorites, and gather the very important information needed to tell everyone exactly what to get him.

It’s not sneaking dessert.

It’s responsible Father’s Day planning.

Stop in and help Dad build his wish list.

Headed to the ballfield, park, lake, camper, or just out for the day?Stock the cooler with snacks that are easy to grab ...
06/16/2026

Headed to the ballfield, park, lake, camper, or just out for the day?

Stock the cooler with snacks that are easy to grab and actually fill you up.

We’ve got easy summer grab-and-go options like cold drinks, cheese curds, cheese cubes, and a variety of beef sticks — perfect for road trips, ballgames, lunch on the go, or hungry kids in the back seat.

Simple. Filling. Cooler-ready.

Stop in before you head out!

Burger night just got easier.Whether you want to fire up the grill with fresh burger or keep it simple with frozen patti...
06/15/2026

Burger night just got easier.

Whether you want to fire up the grill with fresh burger or keep it simple with frozen patties, we’ve got the important part covered:
Tri-State Cheese.

Go classic with Colby Jack, bold with Pepper Jack, creamy with Muenster, or turn up the heat with Thunder Jack.

Because a burger without good cheese is just… unfinished.

Stop in, grab your burger, pick your cheese, and make supper easy this week.

06/12/2026

You know the cheese is good when you buy it for burgers… and half of it disappears before dinner.

We’ve got the cooler stocked with Tri-State Cheese LLC at the farm store this weekend and they’re the kind that make an ordinary meal feel like you actually planned ahead.

Burgers, sandwiches, snack plates, grilled cheese… or standing at the counter cutting “just one more piece” every time you walk by the fridge.

Which, honestly, is usually how it goes at our house.

And part of the reason we carry them is because they’re made by people who care about their products the same way we care about ours.

🧀 The difference between a good weekend and a great weekend?About a pound of cheese.Whether it's burgers on the grill, a...
06/12/2026

🧀 The difference between a good weekend and a great weekend?

About a pound of cheese.

Whether it's burgers on the grill, a charcuterie board, homemade mac & cheese, or just a few slices with crackers, Tri-State Cheese has a way of making everything better.

What's your favorite way to enjoy cheese on the weekend?

🥒 Pickle lovers, this one's for you.Whether you like them sweet, tangy, crunchy, spicy, or somewhere in between, we've g...
06/11/2026

🥒 Pickle lovers, this one's for you.

Whether you like them sweet, tangy, crunchy, spicy, or somewhere in between, we've got a pickle with your name on it.

From Baby Dills and Genuine Dill Pickles to Bread & Butter slices and everything in between, Hershberger's Fine Foods carries more than a dozen varieties of Sechler's Pickles.

The hardest part isn't finding one you'll like...

It's deciding which jar to take home.

What's your favorite kind of pickle? Let us know in the comments! 👇🥒

🥧 Hallmark sells cards. We sell fried pies.Both say "I'm thinking about you."One just tastes a whole lot better.Now you ...
06/10/2026

🥧 Hallmark sells cards. We sell fried pies.

Both say "I'm thinking about you."

One just tastes a whole lot better.

Now you can send our fried pies directly from our website...

Shop online at www.hershbergersfinefoods.com

🥗 Summer Side Dish Showdown! 🥗Every cookout has that one side dish everyone goes back for seconds (and maybe thirds).Is ...
06/09/2026

🥗 Summer Side Dish Showdown! 🥗

Every cookout has that one side dish everyone goes back for seconds (and maybe thirds).

Is it creamy potato salad? Pasta salad loaded with veggies? Baked beans? Coleslaw? Mac & cheese?

We want to know...

👇 What's the one side dish that absolutely has to be at your summer cookouts? 👇

Tell us your favorite in the comments

🍴 Monday Meal Idea: BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Wraps 🍴Need a quick dinner idea for a busy summer evening?Try these easy BBQ...
06/08/2026

🍴 Monday Meal Idea: BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Wraps 🍴

Need a quick dinner idea for a busy summer evening?

Try these easy BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch Wraps! Load up a tortilla with chicken, crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, tomatoes, ranch dressing, your favorite BBQ sauce, and plenty of freshly shredded Tri-State Cheese.

Stop by Hershberger's Fine Foods and grab everything you need:
✔ Fresh chicken breast from the cooler (or canned chicken for an even quicker meal)
✔ Bacon
✔ Fresh produce
✔ Tortillas
✔ Ranch & BBQ sauce
✔ Tri State Cheese for that fresh-from-the-block flavor

Simple, delicious, and on the table in no time.

What's your favorite cheese to add to a wrap? 👇🧀

Address

304 Wendell Avenue
Hicksville, OH
43526

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 5:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 5:30pm
Thursday 8am - 5:30pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

(260) 868-7437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations:

Shortcuts

Share

Category