Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations

Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations In our store you will find a variety of items but our most popular items are our delicious fried pie and award winning cheeses!
(1)

We have many great flavors to choose from! Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Red Raspberry
Black Raspberry
Lemon
Cheesecake
Coconut Cream

Seasonal Flavors:
Bavarian
Chocolate
Rhubarb
Strawberry
Strawberry/Rhubarb
Pecan (September - December)
Pumpkin (October - November)

09/17/2026

What a sweet surprise to see our fried pies on a Sonne Farms reel! 🥧 A big thank-you to whoever brought them out to the farm, and to Sonne Farms for giving them a shout-out. We appreciate you sharing the love!

🍕 It was pizza day at Imago Dei!Each week, someone from the community provides lunch for the students, and today was our...
09/16/2026

🍕 It was pizza day at Imago Dei!

Each week, someone from the community provides lunch for the students, and today was our turn to help. Hershberger’s supplied the cheese and ingredients, and some hardworking hands transformed them into pan after pan of homemade pizza!

We’re thankful for everyone who takes a turn feeding these students throughout the year—and grateful we get to be a small part of it. ❤️

Judging by the empty pans, we’d say today’s lunch was a success! 😄

☔ Today’s forecast: dreary, rainy, with a 100% chance that a fried pie would make things better.Stop by Hershberger’s an...
09/16/2026

☔ Today’s forecast: dreary, rainy, with a 100% chance that a fried pie would make things better.

Stop by Hershberger’s and pick up your favorite—because sunshine may be in short supply today, but fried pies aren’t! 🥧

The new phone has a bigger screen.Finally, technology is focusing on what really matters: viewing fried pies in greater ...
09/15/2026

The new phone has a bigger screen.

Finally, technology is focusing on what really matters: viewing fried pies in greater detail.

We support this innovation.

What’s for supper? How about a warm, cheesy answer? 😋Our Cheesy Ham & Potato Bake combines tender potatoes, savory deli ...
09/14/2026

What’s for supper? How about a warm, cheesy answer? 😋

Our Cheesy Ham & Potato Bake combines tender potatoes, savory deli ham, and creamy Tri State white Cheddar into one comforting meal the whole family can enjoy.

Pick up the ingredients at Hershberger’s, then find the complete recipe here: https://hershbergersfinefoods.com/blogs/news/cheesy-ham-and-potato-bake

🥔🧀

We weren’t at work yesterday, but we couldn’t let Angela’s birthday pass without celebrating her! 🎉🎂Angela joined our te...
09/14/2026

We weren’t at work yesterday, but we couldn’t let Angela’s birthday pass without celebrating her! 🎉🎂

Angela joined our team this summer and has already become an important part of our pie-making crew. She prepares the delicious fillings and helps make pies throughout the week.

Please help us wish Angela a very happy belated birthday! 🥧

09/12/2026

We support balanced diets. One fried pie in each hand.

The judges have spoken—and apparently they like cheese as much as we do. 🧀🏆Tri-State Cheese brought home 11 ribbons from...
09/11/2026

The judges have spoken—and apparently they like cheese as much as we do. 🧀🏆

Tri-State Cheese brought home 11 ribbons from the 2026 Ohio State Fair, including first-place honors for Cojack and Colby Bacon!

Fortunately, you don’t have to wait for the fair to try their award-winning, locally made cheese. Stop by HFF, explore our Tri State Cheese selection and conduct your own very serious taste test.

Your sandwich deserves better. 🥪Stop by our deli for meats and cheeses sliced fresh and exactly the way you like them—th...
09/10/2026

Your sandwich deserves better. 🥪

Stop by our deli for meats and cheeses sliced fresh and exactly the way you like them—thin, thick or somewhere comfortably in the middle.

They’re perfect for packed lunches, quick dinners, snack trays or standing at the refrigerator eating slices straight from the bag. We don’t judge.

What can we slice for you?

It’s Fried Pie Day, which means your plans have officially been upgraded. 😏🥧Flaky outside. Sweet filling inside. Absolut...
09/09/2026

It’s Fried Pie Day, which means your plans have officially been upgraded. 😏🥧

Flaky outside. Sweet filling inside. Absolutely no reason to pretend you’re buying just one.

Stop in, grab your favorites, and maybe pick up an “extra for later.”

We all know how that usually goes.

Address

304 Wendell Avenue
Hicksville, OH
43526

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5:30pm
Tuesday 8am - 5:30pm
Wednesday 8am - 5:30pm
Thursday 8am - 5:30pm
Friday 8am - 6pm
Saturday 9am - 3pm

Telephone

(260) 868-7437

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Hershberger’s Fine Foods / Turnover Creations:

Shortcuts

Share

Category