Amish Creamery

Amish Creamery The Amish Creamery Company offers 60 Flavors of Yoder's Southern Creamery, Sarasota, Florida. Since 2006. Celebrated the start of 20 years, September 06, 2025.

05/18/2026

Just because Spring Break is over. We are still open 7 days a week Mon - Thurs: 1 PM-8 PM, Fri - Sat: 1 PM-10 PM and Sun: 2-8 PM. We welcome your business.

04/20/2026

Spring Break is over for this year. Thank you to all were in and tried our new flavors. Great seeing former visiting families. What a nice reunion it has been.

04/06/2026

We have been very busy with Spring Breaks in the last three weeks.

03/23/2026

Spring break has Sprung. Many new flavors for the new season.

03/08/2026

Our business has been graced with your presence. Last year was so difficult and this year we are ready to serve you better. Thank you for your business.

03/07/2026

Thank you for all the wonderful reviews. We hope to live up to the reviews. Weather is much warmer and we have started to get busier. Spring Break is just around the corner.

02/18/2026

Many new flavors are available for the start of a very successful spring. See you soon.

The Amish Creamery Company to you.
02/14/2026

The Amish Creamery Company to you.

01/31/2026

Some customers have braved the cold so far. We keep the heat on even though our ice cream is Cold. Come visit us.

12/27/2025

Closing another year 2025, we have so much to be thankful for. We appreciate all of our patrons and wish you and your families a Prosperous and healthy 2026.

Address

211 150th Avenue
Madeira Beach, FL
33708

Opening Hours

Monday 1pm - 8pm
Tuesday 1pm - 8pm
Wednesday 1pm - 8pm
Thursday 1pm - 8pm
Friday 1pm - 10pm
Saturday 1pm - 10pm
Sunday 2pm - 8pm

Telephone

+17273978222

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Amish Creamery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category