Cheesy Come, Cheesy Go

Cheesy Come, Cheesy Go We’re also the go to spot for “Build Your Own Cheesecake Bucket”

A unique cheese shop where you can create your own charcuterie and cheese box “on the spot” with artisanal cheese and handcrafted meats or choose something off our unique dining menu.

06/01/2026

This weeks featured cheesecake bucket flavor is:
STRAWBERRY CEREAL KILLER!

We’ve done our research and we’ve FINALLY decided on what hot dog we’re putting on the ROLLER DOG GRILL at Trolley Treat...
05/31/2026

We’ve done our research and we’ve FINALLY decided on what hot dog we’re putting on the ROLLER DOG GRILL at Trolley Treats & Sweets!!!
We started out with a good all beef frank which was great but it lacked the FUN & AMUSEMENT that we like to interject into all our food!!! The only choice had to be a FOOT LONG dog of course and the most famous foot long dog of them all is SABRETT!
Sabrett hot dogs, known for being "New York's #1 Hot Dog" and famous for their signature "snap," are an iconic brand of all beef and pork franks typically sold from the signature blue and yellow pushcarts across New York City!
A bite out of the big apple right here on Main Street at the Trolley Barn Shops!!!
We will be throwing them on the grill Saturday June 6th! Come in and try a sample!

Are you a vendor of farm fresh goodies that would like to occupy an outdoor spot in front of the Trolley Barn this seaso...
05/31/2026

Are you a vendor of farm fresh goodies that would like to occupy an outdoor spot in front of the Trolley Barn this season on Saturday and Sunday?! Farm fresh veggies, etc. Comes with a tiny shop with its own access that could also be used for your setup! We’re looking to host a small farm stop at the Trolley Barn Shops and we’d love to hear from you!

LOOK!!!!!!
05/31/2026

LOOK!!!!!!

Oh dear….we’re at it AGAIN!!!
05/31/2026

Oh dear….we’re at it AGAIN!!!

We’ve taken the space across from our ice cream shop so we can expand with some of our sweet treats!!!! Who is ready for homemade candy?!?!

Yesterday, I had the absolute pleasure of meeting a couple of the guys behind the donuts at the soon to open  Backwoods ...
05/31/2026

Yesterday, I had the absolute pleasure of meeting a couple of the guys behind the donuts at the soon to open Backwoods Bakery in Hanover!!! Nicest guys you’ll ever meet! YEARS of baking experience that even includes a handful of years working with Horst! AND they will be open 24 hrs!!! Cheesecake and donuts 24/7?!?! Sign me up! AND You know me….I’m already working on a collab!!!
I LOVE my Madison roots but Hanover is where I live and is the home of Jazzy B Cleaning Service! I’m so excited to be part of the long awaited business uprise for the Hanover Community!
Go like their page and show them some support!!!!

🥰🥰🥰
05/31/2026

🥰🥰🥰

Summertime Sundays just got better!!!! We’re OPEN 12-4 on Sundays at the Trolley Barn Shops!!! ⭐️Build your own cheese &...
05/31/2026

Summertime Sundays just got better!!!! We’re OPEN 12-4 on Sundays at the Trolley Barn Shops!!!
⭐️Build your own cheese & charcuterie
⭐️Build your own cheesecake bucket
⭐️Smothered Cheesecake slice
⭐️Build your own SALAD
⭐️Dubai Chocolate Strawberry cups
-OR-
Pop into our other shop, Trolley Treats & Sweets for some delicious farm fresh homemade ice cream from Rowlett’s Milkhouse Creamery, LLC!!!

Round 1 of Graduation parties in the books!! Round 2 next Saturday!!!!
05/30/2026

Round 1 of Graduation parties in the books!! Round 2 next Saturday!!!!

LOTS of Shrimp boils going out today! We always find a way to feed people even when the restaurant is closed!!! This dis...
05/29/2026

LOTS of Shrimp boils going out today! We always find a way to feed people even when the restaurant is closed!!!
This dish was so overwhelmingly popular this week that we’re going to begin offering it on Saturday evenings!
SUMMER SATURDAY CAJUN SHRIMP BOIL every Saturday this Summer from 4 PM -7PM! AVAILABLE JUNE 6th - AUGUST 29th!
Call your order in and grab it on the way to your favorite Summertime spot!!!

Address

719 West Main Street
Madison, IN
47250

Opening Hours

Wednesday 11:30am - 7pm
Thursday 11:30am - 7pm
Friday 11:30am - 7pm
Saturday 11:30am - 7pm
Sunday 12pm - 4pm

Telephone

+18127077352

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Cheesy Come, Cheesy Go posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Cheesy Come, Cheesy Go:

Share

Category