Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe

Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe Fish market + Dine In/Takeout
Fish Market: 10am to 8pm *6pm Wed
Kitchen: 2pm to 8pm *CLOSED WEDNESDAY

04/01/2026

RETURNING SATURDAY APRIL 4TH.
Current hours for FISH MARKET everyday 2pm -8pm, KITCHEN 2PM-8PM(no food on Wed.).

02/05/2026

Closing for winter break. Super Bowl Sunday will be your last day to enjoy delicious fried chicken and shrimp. Be sure to call and order your wings to enjoy the game. See you in April.

11/25/2025

CLOSED THANKSGIVING.
WEDNESDAY NOVEMBER 26 OPEN FOR FISH MARKET ONLY. NO HOT FOOD!!! STILL ACCEPTING SHRIMP COCKTAIL PLATTER ORDERS.

10/29/2025

Correction, we are only closed on Wednesday

10/28/2025

NOW CLOSED TUESDAY AND WEDNESDAY FALL/WINTER.

10/05/2025

WE WILL BE CLOSED SUNDAY OCTOBER 5TH.

Commander Cody's seafood: For thursday and friday...Tuna Sashimi, Persian cucumber, spicy black garlic ponzu appetizer, ...
09/12/2025

Commander Cody's seafood: For thursday and friday...

Tuna Sashimi, Persian cucumber, spicy black garlic ponzu appetizer, chili/onion crunch. $15+tax

09/02/2025

CLOSED. SEE YOU ON FRIDAY SEPTEMBER 5TH.

08/04/2025

Commander Cody's Seafood

This week: 1.25 # Lobster with fries,coleslaw, butter and lemon $25.

Address

41 Smith Street
Shelter Island, NY
11964

Opening Hours

Monday 2pm - 8pm
Tuesday 2pm - 8pm
Wednesday 2pm - 8pm
Thursday 2pm - 8pm
Friday 2pm - 8pm
Saturday 2pm - 8pm
Sunday 2pm - 8pm

Telephone

+16317491851

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category