Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli

04/13/2026

In case you run out of jam, here’s a good tutorial to make your own!

04/03/2026

What a nice feature done by the really talented Cassandra McShepard that aired today on TMJ 4!

What started as a simple idea has turned into a standout lunch spot. Mike Hottinger, owner of the Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, says the concept was about doing something different. Read more at the link in the comments.

04/02/2026

🥜🍇 It’s National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day! 🍞✨

And honestly… is there a better place to celebrate than the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli? 😄

Fresh ground peanut butters, over 100 jams, and sandwiches made with love—this is our Super Bowl.

Come celebrate with us today! 🥪❤️

04/01/2026

🚨 BIG ANNOUNCEMENT 🚨

Introducing our NEW hair care product……..
Strawberry Rhubarb Jampoo! 🍓🧴

Why just eat your favorite jam when you can wash your hair with it? 😄

Get ready for luscious locks with the sweet scent of strawberry rhubarb!

Coming soon… 👀

02/18/2026

🌿✝️ It’s Ash Wednesday ✝️🌿

Today marks the beginning of the Lenten season — a time of reflection, renewal… and for many, a day of abstaining from meat.

Good news?
We’ve got you covered. 🥜🍓

At The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli, meat-free isn’t just an option — it’s what we do best.

Fresh-ground peanut butters made daily.
Over 100 incredible jams and jellies.
Classic combos. Creative twists.
All handcrafted right here in West Allis.

Whether you’re observing Lent or just looking for something deliciously different today, a warm, made-to-order PB&J is the perfect choice.

Simple. Comforting. Satisfying. ❤️

Stop in and start the season with something wholesome.

📍 The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli
West Allis, WI

01/24/2026

🥜 It’s NATIONAL PEANUT BUTTER DAY! 🥜

And if there’s one place that takes peanut butter seriously, it’s us.
At the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli, we grind our peanut butters in-house and fresh every day—because peanut butter this good deserves its own holiday.

Stop in today, celebrate with a PB&J (or three), and spread the love the right way 💜🍞
We hope to see you!

01/22/2026

🥶 Too cold to spread the love! 🥶

The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli will be closed tomorrow due to bitter cold weather. We’ll reopen on Saturday when the temps are a little more PB&J-friendly. 💜

Stay warm, friends! ❄️

01/10/2026

♻️ FREE GLASS JARS – GIVE THEM A SECOND LIFE! ♻️

Did you know we go through a lot of jam and jelly here at the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli? That means we always have clean, empty 16-oz glass jars with lids available—and we’d love to see them reused instead of tossed! 💚

If you’re a crafter, organizer, DIYer, teacher, or garage tinkerer, stop in anytime and grab some—they’re FREE!

✨ Great uses for our 16-oz jars:
🖍 Craft supplies (paint, brushes, beads, glitter)
🕯 Homemade candles
🪴 Small planters or herb starters
🧵 Sewing notions (buttons, pins, thread)
🔩 Garage storage for screws, nails & bolts
🍪 Pantry storage (rice, pasta, flour, snacks)
🎨 Classroom or art room organization
🐾 Pet treats
🧂 Homemade spice blends or rubs
🎁 DIY gifts & gift packaging

♻️ Reuse. Repurpose. Get creative.
📍 Just ask at the counter—we’re happy to help you grab some!

Thanks for helping us keep things local, creative, and sustainable 💜

01/08/2026

🔥🌶️ TURN UP THE HEAT AT THE PB&J DELI! 🌶️🔥

Sweet meets spicy in our Spicy Jam Assortment, and it’s not for the faint of heart 😏

✨ Featured flavors include:
🌶️ Hot Pepper
🫐🔥 Blueberry Jalapeño
🍒🔥 Cherry Jalapeño
🍑🔥 Peach Jalapeño
🍓🔥 Raspberry Jalapeño
🫑 Sweet Pepper

Perfect on a PB&J, incredible on a grilled cheese sandwich, or bold enough to steal the show on a charcuterie board 🧀🥖

Come grab a jar (or a sandwich!) and see why sweet + heat = perfection ❤️‍🔥
📍 Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli | West Allis

Which spicy jam are you trying first? 👇🔥

01/03/2026

🥜🍇 We’re at the Oak Creek Winter Farmers Market TODAY! 🍇🥜

Come visit The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli from 9 AM–1 PM and say hi! 👋
We’re excited to be sampling one of our newest creations: Chardonnay Wine Jelly 🍾✨

Stop by, grab a taste, and discover a whole new way to love jelly—sweet, smooth, and a little fancy 😉
Perfect for cheese boards, PB&J upgrades, or gifting! 🧀🥖🍞

📍 Oak Creek Winter Farmers Market
⏰ 9:00 AM – 1:00 PM

We can’t wait to see you there! 💛🥜🍓

12/31/2025

🎉🥳 Happy New Year from the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli! 🥳🎉

We’ll be closed for New Year’s as we take a little time to rest, recharge, and get ready for an amazing year ahead 💛🥪

📅 We will reopen on January 2, fully stocked with your favorite peanut butters, jams, and PB&J creations!

Thank you for all the love and support — we can’t wait to spread more joy (and peanut butter 😄) in the new year!

✨ Cheers to a sweet New Year! ✨