Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli

07/21/2026

We’re launching a new local fundraising program for schools, teams, churches, and community groups. Organizations earn a percentage of every sale while supporters receive handcrafted peanut butters and jams from the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli. We’re currently looking for a few local groups to participate in our first fundraising season.

07/16/2026

Check out our cool giveaway over on our TikTok page!

07/04/2026

Just a reminder that the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli will be CLOSED tomorrow, Friday, July 4th, so our team can enjoy Independence Day with their families.

We hope everyone has a safe, fun, and happy Fourth of July! 🇺🇸🎆

We’ll see you when we reopen on Sunday July, 5th.

❤️🥜🍇 The Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli Team

05/31/2026

I had to bring the big guns out to the Greenfield farmers market! Happening today from 10 AM to 2 PM. It’s a great day for a farmers market, farmers market, so stop on down to Konkel Park in Greenfield. With Carolyn Hottinger

05/29/2026

🥯 NEW SANDWICH SPECIAL ALERT! 🫐

Sweet. Savory. A little unexpected. A whole lot delicious.

We’re featuring an Everything Bagel topped with your choice of creamy cream cheese or tangy goat cheese, finished with a generous layer of rich blackberry jam.

The savory crunch of the bagel, the smooth cheese, and the sweet blackberry flavor come together for a combination that’s simple, unique, and seriously good.

Are you team:
🧀 Cream Cheese
or
🐐 Goat Cheese?

Stop by the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli and give our latest special a try before it’s gone!

05/17/2026

We are set up at the Greenfield farmers market that is going on from 10 AM to 2 PM today! We are sampling all of our nut butters and some of our amazing natural preserves.

04/13/2026

In case you run out of jam, here’s a good tutorial to make your own!

04/03/2026

What a nice feature done by the really talented Cassandra McShepard that aired today on TMJ 4!

What started as a simple idea has turned into a standout lunch spot. Mike Hottinger, owner of the Peanut Butter and Jelly Deli, says the concept was about doing something different. Read more at the link in the comments.

04/02/2026

🥜🍇 It’s National Peanut Butter & Jelly Day! 🍞✨

And honestly… is there a better place to celebrate than the Peanut Butter & Jelly Deli? 😄

Fresh ground peanut butters, over 100 jams, and sandwiches made with love—this is our Super Bowl.

Come celebrate with us today! 🥪❤️

04/01/2026

🚨 BIG ANNOUNCEMENT 🚨

Introducing our NEW hair care product……..
Strawberry Rhubarb Jampoo! 🍓🧴

Why just eat your favorite jam when you can wash your hair with it? 😄

Get ready for luscious locks with the sweet scent of strawberry rhubarb!

Coming soon… 👀